Opinion: 32 Years Later, History Poised to Repeat Itself at City Hall

An opinion column written 32 years ago by Mary Ann Lindley, a former journalist and opinion writer for the Tallahassee Democrat, could almost have been written about the current controversy at Tallahassee City Hall.

At the time, a new City Commission majority was moving to remove longtime City Manager Dan Kleman. Today, a newly elected progressive majority is moving to remove City Manager Karen Jumonville.

The similarities are striking.

In 1994, Commissioner Scott Maddox said he liked and respected Kleman, despite supporting efforts that threatened his job. Today, Mayor Jeremy Matlow has expressed similar sentiments about Jumonville.

Lindley also raised concerns about elected officials interfering in personnel decisions involving professional city employees. That same issue has surfaced amid questions about whether the new majority intends to replace senior city staff.

Then-new Commissioner Ron Weaver claimed an electoral mandate for his actions. Matlow has similarly cited a mandate from voters to justify the new majority’s direction.

Perhaps most relevant is Lindley’s discussion of a six-month cooling-off period that would prevent newly elected commissioners from immediately firing an experienced city manager.

The following column, published 32 years ago, raises a question that remains relevant today: Should winning an election justify immediate personnel upheaval at City Hall?

At City Hall, the Demagogues are Gathering Steam

Mary Ann Lindley | March 8, 1994

Suddenly it looks as if City Manager Dan Kleman may be packing up his wry, commanding managerial style and taking it elsewhere. Meanwhile, we’ll be stuck with a trio of City Commission munchkins pursuing their petty ambitions.

No need feeling sorry for Kleman. However Wednesday’s commission meeting shakes down, he’ll be fine — probably snapped up by any number of organizations across the country that know of his talent in public administration.

Feel sorry instead that an exceptionally well-run local government is at risk if the threesome has its way. It’s hard to know which is the most deliriously self-serving: Ron Weaver, Penny Herman or Scott Maddox.

Weaver, helped into office by the police union, has led the coup. We know the Police Benevolent Association is peeved over Kleman’s choice of a police chief. What we don’t know is Weaver’s own grievances with Kleman, whom he scarcely knows. He suggests only that he has a mandate — though one he failed to tell us voters about during his campaign.
Weaver did tell us that he’d take his time and learn his job before doing anything rash. Perhaps it’s rash to say Weaver intentionally lied — but he did lead us to believe he would be rational and not deal in hidden agendas.

Patronage, Penny?

If Mayor Penny Herman has her way, city employees had better scamper when she strides through City Hall with furrowed brow.
Herman would apparently like a return to the good old days of patronage, where commissioners have a hand in determining who is fired and hired.
The charter says commissioners set policy and the city manager handles personnel. That’s so the city will hire the most skilled, not merely the most well-connected. Kleman finally took the liberty of reminding Herman of this, and unimpeachable sources say Herman was highly displeased. Now she’s flexing her muscle.

Finally, there’s elusive Scott Maddox, who has made no secret of using his city post as a step up to the Legislature. He also happens to be the son of Charles Maddox, state president of the aforementioned unhappy PBA. Scott Maddox is definitely in a quandary. He has said he generally likes and respects Kleman, yet he seems willing to do Daddy’s bidding first and foremost. That’s particularly myopic if, later on, he hopes to convince district voters he’s his own man.

Nobody’s perfect, but…

Kleman has run a tight ship for 19 years, calculating the three-out-of-five vote he needs to keep his job — but without losing integrity.

Frank P. Sherwood, FSU’s eminent scholar in public administration, points to Kleman’s demeanor in recent consolidation efforts: “It seemed to me there was no one so well informed and so concerned about the future of the community as Dan Kleman. I know he had real doubts he would be appointed manager in a consolidated government. Yet he did all he could to support the process. It was the kind of selflessness I have come to expect of Dan.”

“It’s risky business for a commission to act so precipitously on a matter so vital to the long-term interests of the community, says Sherwood. So some city charters provide a cooling-off period after an election when there’s a turnover. For six months the city manager can’t be fired.”

Now we see that such an addition to our charter would be good. It might save a new commissioner from plummeting headlong into folly. It might also protect us voters when we elect commissioners who make big decisions for little reasons.

Steve Stewart

Steve Stewart is the founder and editor of Tallahassee Reports which began in 2009 as an online blog. Steve received a Bachelors Degree from Clemson University in 1984 and a Masters degree in Political Science from FSU in 1990. He has been involved with state and local politics since arriving in Tallahassee in 1989.

View all posts by Steve Stewart →

Be the first to leave a comment on this article.

💬

Join the Conversation

Commenting is a benefit of your Tallahassee Reports subscription. Subscribe for $4.99/month or $50/year to participate.

Your subscription also unlocks our full archive, print e-editions, and supports local independent journalism.

Scroll to Top