Matlow Calls for “Calm” While Launching Sharp Attacks Against Opponent

Screenshot

With only three weeks remaining until Election Day, mayoral candidate Jeremy Matlow held a press conference in front of City Hall to address the political fallout related to the resignation of his campaign manager due to her connection to a controversial political attack on a city commission candidate.

The press conference was marked by a striking contrast between his plea for political civility and a series of pointed personal attacks against his opponent.

Matlow began his remarks by decrying the “negative mail, negative TV ads,” and “negative text” currently flooding the race, calling them “tactics that scare good people away”. He issued an explicit “call for calm,” urging all sides to “stop the smears, stop the lies… and stick to the issues”.

However, the majority of Matlow’s subsequent comments focused on the character and professional conduct of his opponent, Daryl Parks. Despite his plea to end “smears,” Matlow accused Parks of “grandstanding,” “villainizing” him, and acting as part of an “old guard” that rules with an “iron fist”.

Parks responded to Matlow’s press conference attack stating, “Jeremy Matlow’s desperate, mid-press-conference attack reveals exactly what he is: a divider, a bully, and a practitioner of the worst kind of deceptive politics.”

While Matlow insisted that candidates should “stick to the issues,” a significant portion of his address was dedicated to a controversial video related Talethia Edwards, a candidate for city commission seat 3. Matlow detailed allegations involving the Orlando Police Department, including claims of an “illegally” towed car, a “planted bomb,” and a candidate who “failed to appear again and again” in court.

Edwards responded to Matlow’s desire to move forward by stating, “I think that first starts with a formal apology from his campaign, as well as my opponent, P.J. Perez, who they employed this campaign manager on both campaigns, not just one, and a formal apology to the citizens of Tallahassee and the conservative residents in our community that was also misrepresented.”

During the press conference, Matlow argued that it was Parks who was failing to mention issues important to the public, yet Matlow himself spent considerable time discussing these third-party legal matters before pivoting to his own policy platform late in the conference.

Matlow framed the election as a choice between “the chaos of the last eight years” and a move toward a “more transparent and open government”. Paradoxically, he used the platform to criticize Parks for holding a press conference—the first of his campaign—labeling the move as “grandstanding” and a “personal attack” rather than an exercise in the transparency Matlow claims to champion.

In another rhetorical shift, Matlow characterized the current City Hall leadership as a “tiny faction of power players” and a “stubborn 3-2 majority” that “frustrate[s] the will of the voters”. Yet, when discussing regional issues like AI data centers, he noted that the combined city and county perspective often results in a “9 to 3 vote,” placing himself and Commissioner Porter in the minority against a broad consensus he otherwise dismissed as a “tiny faction”.

As the race enters its final stretch, Matlow continues to position himself as the only candidate with “real policy proposals,” even as his own rhetoric fluctuates between a demand for a higher road and the very “negative” tactics he publicly condemns.

Steve Stewart

Steve Stewart is the founder and editor of Tallahassee Reports which began in 2009 as an online blog. Steve received a Bachelors Degree from Clemson University in 1984 and a Masters degree in Political Science from FSU in 1990. He has been involved with state and local politics since arriving in Tallahassee in 1989.

View all posts by Steve Stewart →

Be the first to leave a comment on this article.

💬

Join the Conversation

Commenting is a benefit of your Tallahassee Reports subscription. Subscribe for $4.99/month or $50/year to participate.

Your subscription also unlocks our full archive, print e-editions, and supports local independent journalism.

Scroll to Top