Tallahassee’s newly elected progressive majority wasted little time exercising its political power Wednesday, voting 3-2 to fire City Manager Karen Jumonville during Mayor Jeremy Matlow’s first commission meeting. The controversial decision came despite a provision in Jumonville’s employment contract requiring four votes for termination and followed days of reports about behind-the-scenes efforts to remove her.
Matlow, Commissioner Jack Porter and newly elected Commissioner P.J. Perez supported the termination. Commissioners Dianne Williams-Cox and Curtis Richardson opposed the move.
The commission also voted to appoint Deputy City Attorney Lou Norvell as interim city manager, effective immediately.
Jumonville, a 27-year city employee, was selected in June to replace retiring City Manager Reese Goad and officially assumed the position October 1.
Matlow argued the selection process was flawed and said he could not establish the relationship necessary to work with Jumonville.
“We can’t move forward as a city with a city manager that doesn’t have a relationship with the mayor that’s based on a trust and mutual respect,” Matlow said.
Porter echoed those concerns, saying Jumonville had failed to demonstrate that her leadership would bring the changes voters demanded.
“She has had over a month to demonstrate to me personally and to the residents that things would be different under her leadership,” Porter said. “And she has failed to do that.”
Perez characterized Jumonville’s appointment as an effort by the previous commission majority to preserve its influence following the election.
“I think this was the outgoing regime’s attempt to maintain a preferred administrator from an impending electoral shift,” Perez said.
However, Richardson and Williams-Cox strongly criticized the decision and its potential consequences.
“I’m embarrassed about how this played out,” Richardson said. “I almost want to say I’m pissed off because I was kept totally in the dark about all of these issues until I started getting calls from the media.”
Williams-Cox raised concerns about the uncertainty facing city employees following the leadership change.
“We have employees who are worried about whether they’re going to be able to continue to have a livelihood through the end of the year,” she said.
The firing also raises significant legal questions.
Jumonville’s contract required a four-vote supermajority for termination. The new majority voted to invalidate that provision, arguing it conflicted with the city charter’s requirement that the manager serve at the commission’s pleasure.
City Attorney Amy Toman warned that the decision exposed the city to potential litigation. Jumonville has retained attorney Tiffany Cruz.
During the meeting, Matlow proposed a three-year consulting agreement paying Jumonville $285,000 annually if four commissioners supported her removal. The proposal failed to secure the necessary support.
Norvell, who contributed to the campaigns of Matlow and Perez, will assume responsibility for managing city operations without additional compensation or contractual protections.
“I think that we need change, and I think we need better government,” Norvell told commissioners.
Be the first to leave a comment on this article.