The Leon County Commission’s unanimous approval of a proposed fire services agreement with the City of Tallahassee represents a significant step toward ending a contentious dispute that has divided local officials for nearly two years during an emergency meeting on Monday.
Leon County Chairman Christian Caban, who spearheaded the agreement, said “The framework of this deal is specifically designed by our Mayor-elect Jeremy Matlow and myself so that way in the future public safety can’t be politicized.”
District 4 Leon County Commissioner Brian Welch said, “I think this is an example of good government. A good government board that works together that listens to each other in the best interests of our community.”
The agreement provides a framework for long-term stability, improved financial oversight, county ownership of six fire stations, construction of a new southside station and a revised firefighter work schedule.
However, significant financial questions remain unresolved.
The proposed transition to a 42-hour firefighter workweek could increase fire department expenditures by approximately 18% to 20%, according to estimates based on comparable departments. The actual impact on property owners remains uncertain.
Additionally, the agreement calls for changing the city’s method of collecting fire assessments from utility bills to a uniform collection method, potentially based on building square footage and including vacant land.
While the political dispute appears closer to resolution, the financial implications, including future assessment rates and their distribution among property owners, remain to be determined.
County Commission Provisions
The approved memorandum of understanding (MOU) includes 21 provisions, including 15 recommendations from the Fitch Report previously approved by the County Commission.
The county-supported provisions include requiring the city to submit an annual fire services budget, maintaining reserves equal to 20% to 30% of annual expenditures, conducting annual independent audits and establishing performance measures for response times, staffing and service delivery.
The proposal also calls for conducting rate studies every three years instead of every five years and establishing a new assessment methodology, preferably based on building square footage.
Another significant provision involves county ownership of Fire Stations 10 through 15. The county would purchase the six stations from the city for approximately $1.9 million and lease them back to the city for $1 annually.
County commissioners previously supported a 10- to 15-year agreement. However, the proposed MOU calls for a 20-year agreement that would automatically renew unless either government provides at least three years’ notice.
Additional Provisions Could Increase Costs
The proposed MOU includes five additional provisions based on an outline provided by the County Chairman, along with another recommended by county staff.
One provision commits the city and county to constructing Fire Station 17 on the southside of Tallahassee/Leon County at a maximum target cost of $20 million.
Another provision would align future fire assessment rate studies with the city’s collective bargaining negotiations, which generally occur every three years.
The most consequential provision would accommodate the city’s proposed transition to a 42-hour firefighter workweek, commonly called a 24/72 shift schedule.
The city has requested that the county agree to increase fire services assessments and fees, if financially necessary, to cover its proportionate share of the additional costs.
Importantly, the proposal contemplates implementing these increases during the final year of the existing agreement, beginning October 1, 2027, rather than waiting for the new long-term agreement to take effect.
Other provisions would require both governments to release disputed claims associated with the current agreement, withdraw termination notices and extend the existing agreement for one year while negotiations continue.
Will Fire Services Expenditures Increase?
The central financial question facing county commissioners is how much the new agreement will increase the cost of providing fire protection.
The proposed 42-hour workweek is expected to increase personnel expenditures. The Fitch analysis suggests an increase of approximately 18% to 20% in comparable departments, but the specific dollar estimate for Tallahassee was not provided.
The proposed $20 million Fire Station 17 project represents another potential expenditure, although the agenda does not specify how construction costs would be divided between the city and county.
The acquisition of six existing stations would also require approximately $1.9 million in county expenditures, although county staff reports that adequate funds are available.
Meanwhile, the proposed reserve requirements, future assessment methodology and expanded capital obligations could affect how much property owners ultimately pay.
Next Steps
With the County Commission and City Commission approval the MOU, staff from both governments will begin negotiating the final long-term agreement.
The proposed schedule calls for the city to complete collective bargaining negotiations related to the 42-hour workweek by February 2027.
In March 2027, both commissions would consider the new master agreement, and a consultant would be selected to evaluate the cost of the workweek change.
By June 2027, the governments would seek to adopt a new rate study and begin the statutory process necessary to implement higher assessments for fiscal year 2028.
The county would acquire the six fire stations by September 2027, while the new assessment methodology would be developed for implementation in fiscal year 2029.
The long-term master agreement would take effect October 1, 2028.
Be the first to leave a comment on this article.