Local Group Moves Closer to Purchasing Killearn Golf Club

Local Group Moves Closer to Purchasing Killearn Golf Club

A recent vote by the Killearn Homeowners Association (KHA) has made it a real possibility that a local group will soon own the struggling Killearn Golf & Country Club.

Based on discussions with interested parties, the unanimous KHA vote was required to amend the terms of a settlement agreement which was signed by the KHA and Barton Tuck – the current owner of the golf course – several years ago. 

The vote has cleared the way for Killearn Golf Properties, LLC (KGP) to move forward with their plan to purchase the course from Mr. Tuck who has owned the club since 1987.

The group, which was registered with the state of Florida in August 2019 and is headed up by local businessman Jimmy Graganella, has been in negotiations with Tuck over the last two months.

Graganella, who grew up in Tallahassee and graduated from FSU, owns several Tallahassee based insurance companies that employees approximately 300 people. He is also the owner of Mom & Dad’s Italian Restaurant and a part owner of the Blue Halo. Both restaurants are located in Bannerman Crossings and employee about 100 people.

Why did Graganella get involved with purchasing the club?

“I met my wife at the club, so keeping the club alive means something to me and I did not see anyone else stepping up to make sure the club survived,” said Graganella.

Graganella said after the purchase it will be important add new members as soon as possible. Also, the new ownership structure will provide opportunities for equity investment by members that will generate credits for the investors at the club.

KGP representative Ron Tolliver told Tallahassee Reports that Barton Tuck was sent an agreement containing the terms and conditions for the purchase of Killearn Country Club approximately ten days ago.

Support Local Journalism by Signing Up
for a $50 TR Annual Subscription

Tolliver said he does not anticipate any significant issues to arise and is working toward a closing by year’s end.

Tolliver said after the purchase “the plan is to focus on membership retention and growth.  Our goal is to remake Killearn into Tallahassee’s most desirable club for golf, tennis, swim, fitness and social activities.” 

The Killearn Golf & Country course has been in a state of decline for a number of years. However, the decline appeared to accelerate shortly after the Tallahassee City Commission voted in April 2017 to allow Mr. Tuck to develop part of the North Course as a way to secure the financial resources to upgrade the 50 year-old facilities.

What followed the city commission vote were broken promises and controversy.

Members became disillusioned with Tuck’s failure to make improvements. Tuck blamed the lack of movement on disgruntled Killearn Estates residents who filed lawsuits that took years to resolve.

There were the federal indictments of local officials which included local businessman J.T. Burnette. Burnette was an important part of the development deal.

And then, the Southwood golf course was sold to a group of local owners for approximately $1,000,000. The sale price impacted the value of Killearn and further complicated the proposed redevelopment.

Ironically, during Mr. Tuck’s move to redevelop the property back in 2014, a group of Killearn Estates residents attempted to purchase the club, but were turned down.

Now it looks like local ownership will get a chance to revive a club that was once a yearly stop for the PGA Tour from 1969-1989, playing host to the likes of Arnold Palmer, Lee Trevino and Chi Chi Rodriguez.

8 Responses to "Local Group Moves Closer to Purchasing Killearn Golf Club"

  1. The reason that Southwood, a wonderful course, was dumped by St. Joe for $1,000,000 is that expensive memberships are not affordable, especially for residents of Leon County, young and old. Maintenance, salaries, taxes and upkeep are ongoing concerns for all clubs. This leads to the newly renovated, very expensive and totally private, Thank You, Seminole Legacy Golf Club. Why is FSU, a public university, allowed a private club when it goes hat in hand to the state every year for funds? I realize that paying millions to two head football coaches and their assistants puts a strain on the Seminole athletic budget.

  2. Sounds like a possible good thing might happen. Many more, financially capable, private investors should be solicited for the obvious considerable changes and upgrades expected. Several hundred would not be an unreasonable number of investors who would then be more inclined to participate in its activities and help develop hundreds more memberships to get the proverbial ball rolling toward success. Time will tell -good luck on their efforts. FCC

  3. “Now it looks like local ownership will get a chance to revive a club that was once a yearly stop for the PGA Tour from 1969-1989” ……………… I remember my Dad taking me to one of the PGA Tournaments in the early 70’s.

  4. I like the idea of a local hospitality and insurance expert getting control of the property.
    Tuck has no local interest, is likely too old to handle such a business entity, as demonstrated by bad business decisions along with a general cranky old man attitude.
    Go get it Jimmy. Good luck!

  5. Be wary of this. Friend of mine who was a partner in the insurance companies mentioned here, was on a trip and when he returned, he had been removed. This has been ‘a few’ years ago and the ‘remover’ is named in this article.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.