A growing controversy is unfolding in Leon County as public school officials grapple with the prospect of closing or consolidating schools amid years of declining enrollment and tightening budgets.
At a recent school board meeting, members debated whether to begin formal discussions about school consolidation, a move proponents say could help stabilize the district’s finances by reducing operating costs and directing funds toward classrooms rather than under-used buildings. School Board Member Alva Smith cited state Department of Education data showing several schools operating at less than 70 % capacity, arguing that failing to act would be fiscally irresponsible.
“We need to have this conversation now, or the inevitable will be decided for us,” Smith said during the session, warning that continued decline could deepen budget shortfalls and erode educational quality.
“When we keep too many under-enrolled schools open, we’re spreading our money too thin,” Smith said. “Closing or consolidating schools could free up funding to pay teachers more and help us retain quality educators, which directly benefits students.”
Smith emphasized that Leon County has struggled to stay competitive with neighboring districts on teacher pay, an issue that has fueled concerns about staff retention and morale. Redirecting funds from facility maintenance, utilities, and administrative costs, she said, could provide a meaningful boost to salaries without cutting academic programs.
But the idea of closures has drawn fierce pushback from other board members and community advocates who fear the social and cultural toll of shuttering neighborhood schools. Board Chair Dr. Marcus Nicolas called consolidation talk “premature” until Superintendent Rocky Hanna presents a broader cost-savings proposal. “Neighborhood schools are essential hubs for each community they serve,” Nicolas said, emphasizing a commitment to transparency and careful planning.
The district’s enrollment has dipped steadily in recent years, losing thousands of students to charter schools, private schools, and homeschooling — trends exacerbated by Florida’s expanding voucher programs that allow state education dollars to follow students out of the traditional public system.
Superintendent Hanna has acknowledged financial pressures but stopped short of endorsing closures, stressing the need to protect classroom resources and support staff while exploring alternatives such as co-locating programs or expanding early education offerings in under-used facilities.
Parents and community leaders remain divided: some see consolidation as necessary to preserve long-term quality, while others warn that closing schools could disrupt students’ lives and weaken local neighborhoods.
The issue is sure to come up during future board meetings and during the LCS retreat scheduled for January 26, 2026.
LCS Controversey Over Closing Schools Emerges added by Steve Stewart on
View all posts by Steve Stewart →
This is what concerns me – a father of an 8 year old boy with special needs.
The School Board and the Superintendent are focusing on wrong things. Answer “why” parents are pulling their students out of the public school system! The answer is MANY have lost faith in Administration, the Board, and the Superintendent to provide TOP QUALITY education to our young people. It’s really this simple. There will always be a percentage that will elect to send their children to a private school. The majority have made the move to alternatives because the District’s quality of education has dropped to unimaginable lows. I say you need the reduced class sizing to dig the District out of the hole it’s dug. And I, for one, will not vote to re-elect Hanna.
David, that was my first thought as I read this article. Make lemonade from the lemons!
Barry
I have said this several times already……….I remember back when we Voted to shrink the Class Rooms so the Teachers could have more one on one time helping the Students. Take advantage of this to do what we Voted for.
Do you ever post non-biased articles? This news source is such a disgrace now. Very uncredible and embarassing.
How is this article biased?